Forum Index | Register | Contact Us

August 28, 2008

Did the Cards use an illegal player on Wednesday?

Filed under: fanhome | by BleacherBum593 @ 1:46 pm
I asked Derrick Goold the following and thought maybe somebody here might know the answer to my question.


Quote:

On Saturday night, Josh Phelps was ejected by home plate umpire Mike Muchlinski in the 8th inning of the Memphis game vs Omaha. The PCL reviewed the altercation and suspended Phelps for 2 games. He served game 1 on Tuesday and last night (Wednesday) would have been game 2. However, the Cards purchased his contract, brought him up and played him last night. Doesn't the suspension follow him to whereever he goes and he should not have been allowed to play last night?

Derek Jeter

Filed under: fanhome | by djwhokid @ 11:47 am
The guy is a hall of famer no doubt but it is just getting brutal watching him play shortstop. May I suggest the Yankees signing Rafael Furcal and moving Jeter to LF?

We need to talk

Filed under: fanhome | by RockintheRed @ 7:22 am
OK, we get it. The Cards, despite the injuries, the hard luck, the baffling roster moves, and the seemingly uncatchable Brewers ahead of them, aren't willing to give up yet. This is in a way similar to last year, when the "walking zombies" that were the Cardinals managed to stay just close enough that we couldn't give up on them until the very end of the season. This year, I believe the Cards are much more capable of playing this one out until the very end, but they need to keep it close. Last night's game was close, alright. They needed to win yesterday, and we can pretty much thank Carlos Villanueva for giving us the spark we needed to come back.


The graph above, grabbed from FanGraphs (click to enlarge), shows just how important that 8th inning was. Whether it was because of the trash-talking Villanueva is impossible to prove, but it sure seemed apparent that he played a part in awakening the slumbering offense. After Joe Mather's strikeout with the bases loaded in the bottom of the 7th, the Cards had a 13.9% Win Expectancy (WE) - the Brew Crew were up 3-1 and needed only 2 more scoreless innings to cap the two-game series sweep. By the end of that next 8th inning, however, the Win Expectancy for the Cardinals had jumped to 92.3%. Albert's double sent it from 17.0% at the end of the top of the 8th to 27.8%. Ryan Ludwick's RBI double sent it to 48.3%. Troy Glaus' RBI single-turned-double stretched the WE to 74.1%. Yadier Molina's small ball grounder kept it at 73.9%, and Aaron Miles' run-scoring ground ball brought the WE to 86.6%. After Cesar Izturis' flyout to end the inning, the Cards had jumped 75.3 percentage points to 92.3%. Talk about a wake-up call.

Bernie Miklasz has a good write-up on the whole Villanueva-Pujols incident. Take a looksy and determine for yourself if the trash-talking had anything to do with the late-inning comeback. All I know is, if this quote from Pujols doesn't scare the crap out of you, then you're either lying or dead:
“I told him to shut up and go to the dugout, he doesn’t have to do that. That’s when he said something in Spanish that I don’t want to say to you guys. But that’s when I got fired up. I told him to stop and come and say that to my face, but he was running away. That’s alright. I’m going to see him later.”
No matter what city, county, or country you're from, Albert will find you. And seek revenge.

As for the Cardinals, they're not out yet.

Question of the Day: Did Albert's fiery conversation with Villanueva spark the Cardinals' late-inning rally, or was it merely a coincidence?


More...

Minor league games thread - Thursday, August 28

Filed under: fanhome | by Coop @ 12:35 am
The Iowa Cubs are at Memphis Redbirds @ 7PM.
Probables: Clayton Mortensen vs Randy Wells.
Memphis Redbirds: Home
Redbirds : Memphis Commercial Appeal
AM 560 Sports 56 WHBQ - The Voice of the Fan!

The Arkansas Travelers are at Springfield Cardinals @ 7PM.
Probables: Brandon Dickson vs Keith Weiser.
Springfield Cardinals
JOCK 98.7 FM

Quad City River Bandits are at Burlington Bees @ 7PM.
Probables: Richard Castillo vs Daniel Gutierrez..
Quad Cities River Bandits: Home

The Johnson City Cardinals have a scheduled off day.
Johnson City Cardinals: Home
This league is taking some kind of break. (1st half Playoffs?)

The Batavia Muckdogs are at Williamsport Crosscutters @ 6PM.
Minor League Baseball: Clubs: Batavia Muckdogs

The St. Lucie Mets are at Palm Beach Cardinals @ 6PM.
Florida St. scoreboard
Florida State League: Scoreboard: Scoreboard
Palm Beach Cardinals: Home

MiLB Standings
USATODAY.com
MiLB team schedules
Minor League Baseball: Schedule: Schedule
Minor League Baseball: Multimedia: Gameday Audio

Best News Blog
Cardinals Best News Links

Arizona Fall League
Minor League Baseball: News: Article
Bird Land » Blog Archive » Wallace, Pop, seven others get Fall call

Off topic:
The Big Guys have a scheduled off day.

rally
STLtoday - Cards rally for win

late
Down but never out: Cards rally late | stlcardinals.com: News

Hummel notes
STLtoday - Ankiel still ailing

Strauss chat transcript
STLtoday - Discussions - Joe Strauss Live

Yahoo schedule
Off day Thursday
MLB - Scores & Schedule Thursday August 28, 2008 - Yahoo! Sports
Going to Houston Friday
MLB - Scores & Schedule Friday August 29, 2008 - Yahoo! Sports

Standings
Regular Season Standings | MLB.com: Standings
Won 74 Lost 60
Wild card standings
STLtoday.com - Sports - Stats, Inc.

MSN schedule
FOX Sports on MSN - MLB - Schedules

Additions and corrections are appreciated.

August 27, 2008

Wednesday, 8/27/08: Not Just Another Game

Filed under: fanhome | by BigRapidsJackass @ 7:29 pm
D'backs lost this afternoon.

Dodgers are losing in the 8th.

D'backs and Dodgers play each other this weekend, so somebody's going to lose ground.

If the Rox complete the sweep tonight, maybe we'll see just a bit of panic set in in Phoenix and LA? Rox would be within 6 of the D'backs, 2 of the Dodgers.

Still a long, long shot ... but still.

The odds aren't in our favor tonight. Lincecum vs. Livan. If they pull this one off, I'll keep paying attention.

Our ace in the hole? Clint Hurdle and Dan O'Dowd, Mr. Septembers. I've never seen a club use the expanded September roster as effectively as they did last year. And if we're within 5 or 6 games on Labor Day, I'd expect the same strategy this year. Starters like Rusch working 3 or 4 innings. Using 7 pitchers in a game. Carrying 35 players on the active roster.

It was fun to watch last year, and it actually worked. It probably won't work again, but I'm just hoping for another chance to watch them try.

If it happens tonight against Lincecum, I'll admit that the magic is back. If it happens ...

ESPN Panther preview

Filed under: fanhome | by lorentrook @ 4:48 pm

Instant Replay Inspires The Dim

Filed under: fanhome | by Grandstander @ 8:52 am
I was reading the article about MLB's decision to go with limited instant replay in this morning's paper and was struck by the foolishness of several of those involved or affected.

We start with Commissioner Selig who for no reason I can fathom, decided to be an absolutist. Asked if replay would be expanded beyond homerun determinations, His Budness responded "There's been some concern that if you start here, look what it's going to lead to. Not as long as I'm commissioner."

Now why would he wish to paint himself into a corner before the experiment has even been tried? What if it is a big hit with the fans and there is a popular desire for it to be expanded to other types of calls? Selig is then going to be stuck with his "not on my watch" stance and will have to oppose the popular demand not on the grounds of his defending something good, but on the grounds of his having pointlessly drawn a line in the sand and made a stand. Wouldn't it have been a lot more intelligent to say "We're giving it a limited try out. If it works, we may expand it somewhat, or we may continue to restrict it to homerun calls. If it isn't working, we will eliminate it." Instead, he has forted up with an inflexible position before any results are known.

Apparently not wishing for Selig to appear the lone dummy in this, Kenny Rogers decided to go the partisan route and blame the Yankees and Alex Rodriguez for the rule change. Rogers says that the decision arose from Arod having lost a homerun this past May to an umpire's incorrect judgment. He thinks instant replay is a draconian response to that..."It overshot the mark by far, what, just because in a Yankee game someone didn't get a homer? Please, it's happened thousands of times. That's part of the game, that's the beauty of the game. Mistakes are made."

Ah, so the beauty of the game is the umpires getting the calls wrong? That's why I watch, isn't it why you watch?

Perhaps the most vapid is the opposition from Baltimore manager Dave Trembly. He seemed to have nothing to say about the need or lack of need for instant replay, but is infuriated by the timing. "I find it very strange that with 30 games to go in the season, they would start it now. I find that very peculiar. If they wanted it so bad, why did they wait until this particular point in time?" Trembly did not elaborate or explain why this was so bad a time, nor did he offer any suggestions for the proper timing of such a move.

None of the above seem to be much for forward thinking. It isn't difficult to figure out where things will go from here. Of course instant replay will be retained once it has been tried. We have the examples from the other major sports, all of which have expanded use of replay once it was started and of course ultimately, Selig or no Selig, so will baseball.

The driving force will be the fact that the fan at home watching on tv has long had instant replay available. The broadcasts replay the close calls and in most cases, the tv viewer knows better than the umpire whether or not the player was safe or out, the ball foul or fair, whether or not a runner left the basepath, whether or not a phantom tag was real. Once they start making calls congruent with what the fans watching on tv already know, there isn't going to be any going back, that could only be seen as a pointless retrograde. "We started getting the calls right and it wrecked the game, so we are dropping instant replay?" Of course that will not happen.

Finally, a word on the foolishness of one aspect of what they will be doing. MLB has designated the crew chief of each umpiring collective to be the one who looks at the replay and decides to validate or overturn a call. That of course immediately sets up a conflict of interest and places the judgment in the hands of a prejudiced participant. No crew chief is going to happily overturn the calls of the guys he works and travels with for seven months of the year. These are his buddies and he will only permit them to be shown up on national tv if the blown call is too obvious to mask. Otherwise, the tendency will be to uphold calls on all plays save extremely obvious ones. Worse, the crew chief will also be ruling on whether or not he blew the call himself.

It would make a great deal more sense to have an extra offical who does nothing but handle the replay calls. It will be faster than waiting for the crew chief to get to a monitor and look, and fairer than the system that they are deploying where the foxes are guarding the henhouse.

Sound of silence

Filed under: fanhome | by RockintheRed @ 7:10 am
If there was ever an indicator that the Cardinals are slipping away, it's this: the Mets are now tied for second-place in the Wild Card race with an identical record to us. The Cardinals put up a sorry showing last night in what may be the night we let this whole thing slip away. Adam Wainwright could be our saving grace or the nail in our coffin - that's just the way the season has gone.

To make matters worse, Chris Carpenter "may not be activated for several more weeks," a new announcement after all the encouraging propaganda coming out of the Cards camp several weeks ago. We now know that "his 50-toss session in the Busch outfield Aug. 12 'didn't feel as good as it looked,'" according to the Post-Dispatch. If it's really going to be several weeks and the Cards aren't going to make this race close, then what's the point of re-activating him at all? Give him the rest of the season to recover and get ready for a full season in 2009. Matter of fact, assuming the Cards can't get any closer within reach, let Albert get to his 30 homers, 100 RBI-plateau and then let him get the surgery necessary for his elbow.

On Monday I commented on the amount of wishy-washiness coming from TLR, but now we are finally starting to get some answers. Joel Pineiro will indeed stay in the rotation and so will Adam Wainwright, if only on a day-to-day basis. (Insert sarcastic comment here regarding the notion that you should ever consider an ace to be flip-flopped to the bullpen). It's pretty much a no-brainer after the Carpenter news, and I guess they don't have much more to lose by doing so. It at least sets him up for next year, when he'll be back in the starting 5 with his $7.5m salary.

To make matters worse, Tony is using the "Earned It" principle, based on an integrated theorem of Grit and Leadership statistical measures, to guide his decision-making for his September call-ups. That leaves out Colby Rasmus, who has been injured and didn't have the kind of season he was expecting in Memphis this year. If the Cards can't win tonight and stay on the fence going into next month, where's the harm in getting Colby some major league at-bat time when the pressure isn't on? If Tony can find ways to give Felipe Lopez time in LEFT FIELD, why couldn't he find some at-bats for the future of this organization? How in the world has Felipe freakin' Lopez earned anything over Rasmus? I suppose Tony had his eyes closed when Lopez dogged-it with his nonchalant, double-cluth-and-a-crow-hop throw to first base, allowing the runner to beat him to it. That's what kind of player Felipe is, and I guess that's the kind of player we're going to have to live with for the rest of the year.


More...

Game thread #134 - MIL@STL - 8/27/08

Filed under: fanhome | by Coop @ 3:27 am

Minor league games thread - Wednesday, August 27

Filed under: fanhome | by Coop @ 3:20 am
The Iowa Cubs are at Memphis Redbirds @ 7PM.
Probables: Mitchell Boggs vs Jason Stanford.
Memphis Redbirds: Home
Two articles
Redbirds : Memphis Commercial Appeal
AM 560 Sports 56 WHBQ - The Voice of the Fan!

The Arkansas Travelers are at Springfield Cardinals @ 7PM.
Probables: Justin Fiske vs Josh Hall.
Springfield Cardinals
JOCK 98.7 FM

Quad City River Bandits are at Burlington Bees @ 7PM.
Probables: Jameson Maj vs Matthew Mitchell.
Quad Cities River Bandits: Home

The Johnson City Cardinals have a scheduled off day.
Johnson City Cardinals: Home
This league is taking some kind of break. :confused:

The GCL Cardinals are at GCL Dodgers @ 9AM.
This is the last game on their 2008 schedule.
Minor League Baseball: Clubs: GCL Cardinals

The Batavia Muckdogs are at Mahoning Valley Scrappers @ 6PM.
Minor League Baseball: Clubs: Batavia Muckdogs

Doubleheader.
The St. Lucie Mets are at Palm Beach Cardinals @ 4PM.
Florida St. scoreboard
Florida State League: Scoreboard: Scoreboard
Palm Beach Cardinals: Home :duh:

MiLB Standings
USATODAY.com
MiLB team schedules
Minor League Baseball: Schedule: Schedule
Minor League Baseball: Multimedia: Gameday Audio

Best News Blog
Cardinals Best News Links

Arizona Fall League
Minor League Baseball: News: Article
Bird Land » Blog Archive » Wallace, Pop, seven others get Fall call

Off topic:
The Big Guys host the Brewers.
Probables: Adam Wainwright vs LH Manny Parra @ 7PM.

Cardinals website - Home page
The Official Site of The St. Louis Cardinals | stlcardinals.com: Homepage

MSN schedule
FOX Sports on MSN - MLB - Schedules

Additions and corrections are appreciated.
Next Page »
 
>